Bugging Out Solar
A timber frame solar carport at night in a storm
Home / Before the Storm / Any season

Most people buy more generator than they need. A comparison guide.

A bigger generator burns more fuel and makes more noise every hour it runs, whether the house is using the power or not. Here is how to size one for an outage, not for a normal Tuesday.

Bugging Out carport, illustration

In short: The things you can’t do without in an outage, the refrigerator, a gas furnace, some lights and the Wi-Fi, run on about 1,000 watts. A small generator covers that on under 3 gallons of gas a day. A whole-house unit can burn 60 gallons of propane a day.

By Bret, founder of Bugging Out Solar, on the Outer Banks of North Carolina

If you live off the grid full time, you need enough power for everything, every day. An outage is different. It is a few days of getting by, and in those days you can simply leave some things unplugged. Size the generator for that and everything gets smaller, cheaper and quieter.

What the essentials really draw

These are Honda’s published figures. Running watts is what a thing uses once it is going. Starting watts is the brief extra kick a motor needs to get going.

WhatRunning wattsStarting watts
Refrigerator/freezer (Energy Star)132 to 1921,200
Gas furnace fan300 to 875500 to 2,350
46-inch flat screen TV190190
Coffee maker, 4 cup600600
Microwave, 1,000 watt1,5001,500
Sump pump, 1/3 horsepower8001,300
Window air conditioner, 10,000 BTU1,5002,200

Add up a refrigerator, a mid-size furnace fan at 500, the TV and about 100 watts of lights and chargers, and you are near 1,000 watts running. The starting kick of the refrigerator pushes that to about 2,000 for a moment.

What makes people buy big

WhatRunning watts
Electric water heater4,500
Electric clothes dryer5,400
Electric range, one 8-inch burner2,100

Three appliances like these, plus central air, are what turn a 2,000-watt job into a 20,000-watt one. In an outage you can leave every one of them off. Heat water on a camp stove or the grill. Hang the laundry. Cool one bedroom with a window unit.

Four sizes, side by side

These are four real machines, one from each size class, with the makers’ own numbers. They are examples of a size, not recommendations of a brand.

 Small inverterLarge inverterLarge open-frameWhole-house standby
ExampleHonda EU2200iHonda EU7000iSWestinghouse WGen7500Generac Guardian 22 kW
Running watts1,8005,5007,50022,000 on propane
Fuel per hour0.12 to 0.3 gal gas0.32 to 0.8 gal gasAbout 0.6 gal gas2.5 to 3.9 gal propane
Fuel per day, running lightly around the clockAbout 2.8 galAbout 7.7 galAbout 14 galAbout 61 gal
Noise, by the maker53 to 62 dB52 to 58 dB72 dB67 dB at 23 feet
WeightAbout 47 lbAbout 263 lbAbout 197 lbAbout 466 lb, installed
How it startsPull cordButton, pull cord backupButton or remote, pull cord backupBy itself
ChokeManualNone (fuel injected)AutomaticAutomatic

Fuel per hour for the two Hondas runs from a quarter load to full rated load. The Westinghouse figure is its 6.6-gallon tank divided by the maker’s run time of up to 11 hours. The Generac figures are half load and full load. Makers do not all measure noise the same way or from the same distance, so treat those as a rough guide. As a rule of thumb, every 10 decibels sounds about twice as loud.

How to read that

The small one covers the essentials if you don’t start everything at once, and you can carry it with one hand. It will not run a big furnace fan, a sump pump and a microwave together. So you take turns. Unplug one thing for a few minutes while another runs.

The large inverter is quiet and runs nearly everything on the first list at once, including a window air conditioner. It burns close to three times the fuel of the small one, and it takes two people or its wheels to move.

The large open-frame is what most stores stack by the door before a storm. It costs less than the big inverter and makes more power, and it is the loud one on the street. With a 1,000-watt house on it, most of what it can make goes unused while it burns about 14 gallons a day. Its power is also rougher than an inverter’s. Owners report battery power stations (often sold as “solar generators”) that refuse to charge from this kind of generator, and some furnaces that object to it.

The whole-house standby starts by itself and runs everything, electric dryer and all. That is worth a lot to someone who can’t go outside and pull a cord, or whose house is all electric. For everyone else it is a great deal of machine and fuel for a few days a year.

How easy is it to start?

The numbers on the box are watts. What you live with is how the thing starts on a cold morning.

The choke. A cold engine needs a richer gulp of fuel to start, and the choke gives it that. Once the engine is running you open the choke again, and a warm engine doesn’t need it at all. That one lever confuses more people than anything else on a generator. There are three kinds.

  • Manual choke. You close it to start cold and open it once the engine runs. The Honda EU2200i works this way.
  • Automatic choke. The generator does it for you. The Westinghouse WGen7500 has one. It is a real convenience, though an automatic choke can still be fussy on a very cold day.
  • No choke at all. Fuel injection, like a modern car. Honda says the fuel injection on its EU7000iS eliminates the choke and cuts down on carburetor trouble.

Pull cord or button. The EU2200i is pull-start only. The other two start with a button and keep a pull cord as a backup.

Is the button worth paying for? I think so. The biggest reason I have scrapped generators is the pull start jamming up. On a lot of machines the part is hard to find, and it stops being worth the trouble to fix. One small component goes bad and the whole generator is scrap. With electric start you have two ways to get it running, and in my experience the electric start lasts a long, long time. Its small battery does have to be kept charged.

The small levers. Many generators have a fuel shutoff, and some, like the EU2200i, also have a vent lever on the fuel cap that has to be on for the engine to run. Forget either one and the engine starts on the little fuel that is already there, runs a moment and quits. I run a generator nearly every day and I never touch the fuel shutoff, for that reason. It is one more thing to forget.

Stale gas. The case for the shutoff is a generator that sits all year. Gasoline left in a carburetor goes bad, and it is a common reason a generator won’t start when you finally need it. Shutting the fuel off and letting the engine run until it stops burns off most of what is in there. A dual-fuel generator gets around the problem another way: it can run on propane, which doesn’t go stale the way gasoline does. Westinghouse’s dual-fuel version of the same machine makes 6,750 watts on propane against 7,500 on gasoline.

Whichever kind you have, the levers are easy on a calm afternoon and maddening in the dark. That is what the dress rehearsal is for.

The cord matters as much as the generator

A generator belongs well away from the house. That means a long cord, and a long thin cord chokes the power before it gets indoors. Don’t use the cord you hang Christmas lights with.

Cord thickness is called gauge, and the numbers run backward: a smaller number is a thicker wire. The size is printed on the cord, something like 12/3.

What you are running50-foot cord100-foot cord
Up to 1,800 watts12 gauge12 gauge
Up to 2,400 watts12 gauge10 gauge

Those figures are from a generator maker’s chart. For comparison, 1,800 watts is the full rated output of the small generator in the table above.

A cord that is too thin gets warm, and the voltage sags at the far end. Sagging voltage is why a refrigerator hums and won’t start, and why a furnace ignores the call for heat. Use one cord of the right length, not several plugged end to end, and no longer than it takes to put the generator where it belongs. Buy it before the storm, rated for outdoor use, with a plug that fits the outlet on your generator.

The middle road

A small generator and a battery cover more than either one alone. The generator runs a few hours, does the house and fills the battery, then shuts off. That is covered in pair it with a solar generator, and the fuel math is in your generator’s weak point isn’t watts, it’s gallons.

To add up your own house, the generator size calculator lets you pick what you want to keep running.

One thing to do today

Write down what you would keep running in an outage and add up the running watts from the labels. Then add the biggest starting number on the list. That is the size you need. Everything past that is fuel and noise.

For reporters

Use the numbers and quote this piece freely. All we ask is a link back to this page. To reach us, use the form at Talk to Us.

Sources

More from Before the Storm →

Ready when the lights go out

Tell us about your place and what you drive, or plan to. We'll tell you straight what a Bugging Out pool house or carport would do for you.